REVIEW: By Nightfall

Michael Cunningham’s By Nightfall is a story of yearning for something more. Beautifully told with the background of the the SoHo neighbourhood in Manhattan, Peter and Rebecca’s lives become a metaphor for what is needed versus what is desired and the importance of knowing the difference of that.

The Story

Peter and Rebecca Harris are an art curator and a magazine editor, respectively. They live the lives of those in New York City that have enough money to not worry about their lives while still being “average” enough that they aren’t entirely obnoxious or elitist. Slightly above average lives for slightly above average people. But then Rebecca’s young brother, an ex-drug addict who has decided he wants to be an artist or an art curator, comes to stay with them and Peter’s life goes off the rails enough to keep things interested. He becomes enamored with Ethan, thinking of him as the beautiful muse his life has been missing. The pretty young thing that will make everything make sense.  However, Ethan is more of a handful than Peter is able to handle…

The Characters

Peter is a typical middle-aged man in crisis about his life. His wife, Rebecca, is in a similar state of mediocrity but is not stressed out about it. Ethan – or Mizzy (short for “The Mistake”) – is a typical 20-something stoner type with too much time on his hands and not enough boundaries. There are several side characters as well ranging from other middle-aged art dealers or pretentious artists to Peter’s daughter who he’s sure doesn’t love him. To be entirely honest, I was bored by most of the characters. Peter’s love affair was so minor and quick it almost went unwarranted and proved him to be a rather unpleasant person. Rebecca had almost no character at all. Ethan was – as I mentioned before – just a typical druggie type that I have personally had the misfortune of dealing with myself.

Conclusion ★★★

In conclusion I honestly only finished this book for two reasons: 1) This was an audiobook and helped pass the time at my day job (which allows me to wear headphones while I work) and 2) Hugh Dancy was the one reading the audiobook.

Were it not for Dancy’s rather soothing voice, I don’t think I would have made it through. The prose is almost hypnotic and created a beautifully vivid depiction of New York, and there are few things I love more than an author who is capable of such powerful descriptions. However, the story was bland and the characters unrelatable. I am still giving this 3 out of 5 stars, however, because I highly enjoyed Hugh Dancy’s performance for the audiobook (he does voices) and as I said, the descriptions of the city and the artwork were stunningly clear.

Not my taste, but I won’t tell people not to read it.

PS. – Yes there is a male/male “romance” involved in the story, but I would personally not count it as LBGT+ representation.


Published: September 28, 2010

Summary: Peter and Rebecca Harris: mid-forties denizens of Manhattan’s SoHo, nearing the apogee of committed careers in the arts—he a dealer, she an editor. With a spacious loft, a college-age daughter in Boston, and lively friends, they are admirable, enviable contemporary urbanites with every reason, it seems, to be happy. Then Rebecca’s much younger look-alike brother, Ethan (known in thefamily as Mizzy, “the mistake”), shows up for a visit. A beautiful, beguiling twenty-three-year-old with a history of drug problems, Mizzy is wayward, at loose ends, looking for direction. And in his presence, Peter finds himself questioning his artists, their work, his career—the entire world he has so carefully constructed.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s